Homemade Whole Wheat Bread Is Easier Than You Think (2024)

Each year for Christmas, my mother-in-law bakes loaves upon loaves of sandwich bread and gives them to her five children as gifts. I love everything about this. I know the time she has invested into making homemade bread. I value her effort and cherish it immensely. And it tastes delicious, too.

I could list one hundred reasons why baking bread at home is a good idea. Chief among them is that your house will never smell more comforting or homey than when a loaf of bread is rising to golden perfection in your oven.

All the other reasons like the subtle nutty flavor and added fiber in your diet are good, too, but oh, my word, the smell of freshly baked bread is to an adult what petting a kitten is to child—all comfort and love. That nostalgia is hard to beat.

My Adaptation: Whole Wheat Bread

My mother-in-law’s bread is made with lard, water, granulated sugar, and white all-purpose flour. It yields a loaf that is tall and soft, yet sturdy.

For my version of this recipe, I wanted to make a whole wheat sandwich bread with a soft crumb and light but sturdy texture. I’ve adapted my mother-in-law's recipe by using a combination of whole wheat flour and bread flour. I’ve also substituted unsalted butter for the lard, and replaced the water in her recipe with milk.

Nearly 30 pounds of flour and 18 loaves of bread later, the result is a sliceable sandwich loaf that is tender and slightly chewy with a golden crust that’s just thick enough to add body, but not so thick my kids insist I cut it off.

So far, I’ve made PB&J, cold turkey sandwiches, grilled cheese, French toast, stuffed French toast and regular toast with butter and jam. The bread has held up beautifully in every circ*mstance.

Easy Homemade Whole Wheat Bread

You can make this whole wheat bread, too. It's easier than you think.

Start in the morning, and you can have two loaves of freshly baked bread cooling on your countertop by lunch. It only takes 20 minutes of hands-on time. The rest is just rising and baking.

Experimenting To Find the Perfect Loaf

In an attempt to make this recipe as easy and foolproof as possible, I tried various starters, yeasts, sugars, liquids, and flours.

• For my yeast experiments, I decided to use Active Dry Yeast instead of Instant Rapid Rise because I felt like the instant yeast made the loaves rise too quickly and often resulted in over-proofed loaves. Winner, winner, bread for dinner!
• On to sweeteners! I made versions of bread with granulated sugar, honey, and molasses for sweetener. I found honey provided a subtle sweetness and color to the bread I liked. Granulated sugar left the loaves too pale, and molasses too dark.
• Milk or water? You need liquid to activate Active Dry yeast. I use milk instead of water because it creates a more tender crumb. The sugar in the milk also contributes to a softer, more deeply colored crust. That being said, if you’re lactose intolerant feel free to use water.
• When it came to flour, I settled on a combination of whole wheat flour and bread flour. The extra bran in the whole wheat flour can impede rising, which often results in a dense loaf of bread. Bread flour helps counteract this: it's higher in protein than all-purpose flour, which helps create a stronger gluten network during kneading.

By blending whole wheat flour and bread flour, I created a nutty-flavored bread with a light and soft texture, perfect for a sandwich. Feel free to experiment and adjust the flour ratios to your liking. Keep in mind that whole wheat flour reacts differently than bread flour. If you adjust the flour ratios you may also need to experiment with the amount of moisture you add to the dough.

How To Knead the Dough

When it comes to bread, hydration is good. I tend to err on the side of a wetter dough simply because it’s easier to add more flour to dough than it is to add more water.

If the dough feels too wet when you knead, use a bench scraper to help scrape the dough off the counter. Dust the counter and your hands with a tablespoon of bread flour at a time until the dough feels tacky, but not sticky.

If the dough ends up feeling dry and is difficult to knead, you can add more moisture by sprinkling your kneading surface with water as if you were dusting it with flour. Then knead in the water. It’s difficult to knead slimy dough, however, so use only a little water at a time.

How To Know When the Bread Dough Has Risen

The shaped loaves are ready for the oven when they have doubled in size and you can touch the top or make a small cut with a paring knife without the dough collapsing.

If it collapses, the dough has over proofed. In this circ*mstance, you can do one of two things:

• Bake it anyway and use it for strata, bread pudding, French toast, or croutons.
• Or you can punch it down, and let it rise for a third time. The third rising doesn’t always work, but given your circ*mstances, it might be worth a shot.

If all else fails, cry a little. Then start again. It’s only bread. Chances are your family will eat it even if it isn’t perfect. (Speaking from experience here. Ahem.)

How To Store and Freeze Bread

If your day gets away from you and you don't have time to bake your loaves, just cover the bowl and place the dough in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours. Finish the remaining steps when you're ready.

You can also freeze the dough after you’ve finished kneading it, but before you begin the first rise. Here's what to do:

• Place the dough in an oiled plastic bag, and try to remove as much air as possible, leaving just a little for expansion.
• When you’re ready to bake, place the frozen dough in a large buttered bowl. Cover and leave in the refrigerator for 24 hours. This will serve as your first rise.
• Remove the dough from the fridge and bring the dough to room temperature on your countertop.
• Punch down. Divide in half. Shape into loaves. Place into buttered loaf pans. Let rise again and bake as directed.

To freeze the baked loaves, allow the bread to cool completely. Wrap the bread in foil, then place it inside a zip-top bag. Remove as much air as possible.

The bread will keep in the freezer for up to three months. When ready to eat, transfer bread from the freezer to the countertop, keeping it in the wrapping. It will thaw in about 3 hours.

More Bread Recipes

• Homemade Potato Bread
• Homemade Light Rye Bread
• Irish Brown Bread
• Irish Soda Bread
• Anadama Bread